Although both silicone plate and rubber plate have certain elasticity and sealing properties, there are significant differences in their performance, which mainly stems from their different chemical structure and basic materials.
Here's the key performance comparison:
Temperature Resistance: Silicone Sheets: Exceptionally durable. These sheets maintain long-term stability across a wide temperature range from-60°C to +230°C, with short-term tolerance extending up to 250°C or even 300°C. This makes them ideal for high-temperature environments like ovens, baking trays, heat-sealed containers, thermal insulation pads, and electronic component heat sinks. Rubber Sheets: Limited in performance. Specific temperature ranges depend on rubber type: Natural Rubber: -50°C to +70°C (degrades at high temperatures and becomes brittle at low temperatures). Styrene Butadiene Rubber (SBR): -40°C to +100°C. Nitrile Rubber (NBR): -30°C to +120°C (excellent oil resistance). Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EPDM) Rubber: -50°C to +150°C (good weathering and ozone resistance). Fluororubber: -20°C to +200°C or higher (exceptional heat and chemical resistance, though expensive).
Chemical Stability and Aging Resistance: Silicone Sheets: Exhibits exceptional resistance to oxygen, ozone, and ultraviolet radiation. They demonstrate remarkable aging resistance, maintaining flexibility without hardening, cracking, or loss of elasticity even after prolonged use, typically offering an exceptionally long service life. These sheets show good tolerance to polar solvents (such as alcohols, ketones, and certain acids), but exhibit poor resistance to non-polar solvents (e.g., aliphatic hydrocarbons, aromatic hydrocarbons, petroleum-based oils) and strong acids/alkalis, potentially causing swelling or degradation. Rubber Sheets: Aging resistance varies by material type. Natural rubber and styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) are sensitive to ozone and UV radiation, prone to cracking and aging. EPDM and fluororubber demonstrate superior weather resistance. Significant Differences in Chemical Resistance: Nitrile Rubber: Exceptionally oil-resistant (petroleum-based oils, aliphatic hydrocarbons). Fluororubber: Outstanding chemical resistance (resistant to oils, acids, alkalis, solvents). Natural Rubber: Resistant to weak acids/alkalis but not oils/solvents. EPDM: Resistant to water, steam, weak acids/alkalis, and polar solvents, but not oils or hydrocarbon solvents.
In terms of chemical resistance, both types have distinct focuses and should be selected based on specific contact media.
Physical and mechanical properties: Silicone rubber sheets: Mechanical strength (tensile and tear strength) is generally lower than most rubbers. While exhibiting good elasticity, their permanent compression deformation performance may not match certain high-performance rubbers (especially under prolonged high-temperature compression). They demonstrate excellent recovery resilience and maintain good flexibility at low temperatures. Rubber sheets: Typically exhibit higher mechanical strength (particularly tensile and tear strength). Permanent compression deformation performance varies by type and formulation, with some rubbers (e.g., EPDM) performing well. Recovery resilience is generally satisfactory. Low-temperature flexibility depends on material type (e.g., natural rubber performs better at low temperatures while nitrile rubber hardens in cold conditions).

Electrical Insulation: Silicone Sheets: Possess excellent electrical insulation properties with high resistivity and dielectric strength, maintaining stability across a wide range of temperatures and frequencies. Widely used in electronic and electrical insulation applications. Rubber Sheets: Generally exhibit good electrical insulation (especially EPDM), though may not match the purity and stability of silicone. Certain rubbers (e.g., conductive rubbers containing carbon black) can be designed for conductivity or antistatic properties. Conclusion: Silicone demonstrates superior advantages in high-end electrical insulation applications (particularly in high-temperature and high-frequency environments). Biocompatibility and Non-toxic Nature: Silicone Sheets: Exhibits high physiological inertness and exceptional biocompatibility. Easily manufactured into products compliant with Food Grade (FDA, LFGB) and Medical Grade (USP Class VI) standards. Odorless and bacteria-resistant. Rubber Sheets: Vary significantly in biocompatibility. Natural rubber may cause allergies. To achieve Food Grade or Medical Grade certification, strict selection of raw materials and additives (vulcanizing agents, accelerators, anti-aging agents, etc.) is required. These additives carry higher migration risks compared to silicone, potentially emitting rubber odors.
Gas permeability: Silicone sheets: These materials exhibit high permeability to gases (e.g., air) and water vapor. While this property is advantageous for certain applications (e.g., breathable pads, respiratory membrane devices), it may prove disadvantageous in sealing applications. Rubber sheets: Generally have lower gas permeability, particularly butyl rubber, which serves as an excellent airtight material.
Conclusion: Rubber is generally better at making airtight and watertight seals. Surface characteristics: Silicone plate: The surface is hydrophobic (hate water), does not easily adhere to many substances, easy to clean. Rubber plate: The surface characteristics vary depending on the type and formula, some may be sticky.
Cost: Silicone plate: relatively expensive. The cost of raw materials and production costs are usually higher than ordinary rubber. Rubber plate: a wide range of costs. Natural rubber, SBR, NBR and other commonly used rubber costs are lower. Special rubber (such as fluororubber, silicone rubber itself) costs are high.
The final material selection should be determined by application-specific requirements including operating temperature range, contact with chemical media, mechanical load, food-grade/medical-grade compatibility, airtightness needs, and budget constraints.
Both silicone and rubber each demonstrate irreplaceable advantages in their respective fields
